Former Vice President Mike Pence cast the 2024 election as a fight for the future of conservatism and his party as he called on fellow Republicans to reject the “siren song of populism” championed by former President Donald Trump and his followers.
“Should the new populism of the right seize and guide our party, the Republican Party we’ve long known will cease to exist and the fate of American freedom would be in doubt,” Pence said Wednesday afternoon in what his campaign plugged as a major speech at the New Hampshire Institute of Politics at Saint Anselm College.
Pence’s plea comes at a critical time for his campaign, which has been struggling to build momentum since its launch. Four months ahead of Iowa’s kickoff caucuses, Trump remains the race’s undisputed front-runner, while Pence still polls in single digits. Pence, who served four years as Trump’s loyal second-in-command, has tried to paint himself as the most conservative candidate in a crowded Republican field. But he is championing policies that have fallen out of favor with many Republican voters who have embraced Trump’s anti-establishment rhetoric, protectionist trade policies and isolationist worldview.
“If we are to defeat Joe Biden and turn America around, the Republican Party must be the party of limited government, free enterprise, fiscal responsibility and traditional moral values,” Pence argued in his speech. He compared the right’s ascendant populism — generally defined as a focus on ordinary people’s complaints about big government and so-called elites — to the left’s progressivism, calling them “fellow travelers on the same road to ruin.”
Pence, who broke with Trump before the storming of the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, and refused to go along with his efforts to overturn the results of the 2020 election, continued the more aggressive posture he has taken in recent weeks. He went after the former President repeatedly by name.
He quipped that the Republican Party “did not begin on a golden escalator in 2015,” a reference to Trump’s campaign launch in New York, and argued that the former President has abandoned the conservative principles he ran on when Pence was his running mate in 2016.
“When Donald Trump ran for President in 2016, he promised to govern as a conservative. And together we did. But it’s important for Republicans to know that he and his imitators on this Republican Primary make no such promise today,” Pence said. “The truth is Donald Trump, along with his imitators, often sound like an echo of the progressives they seek to replace.”
“The growing faction would substitute our faith in limited government and traditional values with an agenda stitched together by little else than personal grievances and performative outrage,” he added.
Trump, responding on his Truth Social site, accused Pence of going to the “Dark Side” after only speaking well of him for years.
“His advisers have led him down a very bad path!” Trump said.
“The conservative movement and the Republican Party have changed for the better, and nobody wants it to go back to the way it was before,” added Trump’s adviser, Jason Miller.
The ideological shift is, in part, a reflection of changing demographics as the GOP has increasingly become a party of the working class, while Democrats have attracted college-educated voters. Right-wing populism has also been on the rise across Europe and around the globe in response to factors including globalization and mass migration.
Pence, in his speech, called for a course correction, accusing Trump and his followers of abandoning U.S. allies abroad with isolationist policies and ignoring the national debt.
Beyond Trump, he criticized Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, who is polling in second, for using “the power of the state to punish a corporation for taking a political stand that he disagreed with” in his ongoing feud with Disney, one of the largest employers in the state. And he attacked tech entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy, who has become a favored punching bag as he has risen in the polls, for his past statements on raising inheritance taxes.
Pence also accused Trump and his “imitators” of trying to “blatantly erode our constitutional norms,” referencing Trump’s call last year for “the termination of all rules, regulations, and articles, even those found in the Constitution” over his false claims that the 2020 election was stolen.
“You know there’s already a party that embraces appeasement abroad. There’s already a party that would ignore our national debt,” Pence said, adding that this is “not conservatism. It’s Republicanism that prioritizes power over principles.”
Instead, Pence repeatedly hailed the example of President Ronald Reagan, arguing the party must return to his model of limited government, strong national defense and traditional social values, including staunch opposition to abortion rights.
Republicans face a “time for choosing,” he said, referencing a famous Reagan speech. “The future of this movement, of this great party, belongs to one or the other – not both. That’s because the fundamental divide between these two factions is unbridgeable.”